A Utah judge has been prompted to release transcripts from a closed-door hearing concerning whether Tyler Robinson, charged with killing conservative activist Charlie Kirk, should be shackled during court proceedings. State District Judge Tony Graf stated the transcripts must be available by the day's end. Media representatives, including The Associated Press, argued for the public's right to know the details surrounding the closed hearing.
Robinson has been charged with aggravated murder in connection with the shooting of Charlie Kirk on September 10 at Utah Valley University in Orem, Utah. Prosecutors have indicated their intention to pursue the death penalty. During early October, Robinson's defense argued for him to appear in civilian clothing without restraints, aiming to prevent potential bias from jurors.
Following an October 24 closed hearing, Judge Graf allowed Robinson to appear in civilian attire while still imposing the requirement for restraints, highlighting the necessity for court security. In an order dated October 27, Graf noted that restraints would ensure the safety of court personnel and the defendant, preventing disruptions during proceedings.
On Monday, the judge reiterated the importance of transparency in the judicial process, stating it as a foundational principle. He instructed that the released transcripts include limited redactions regarding security protocols. Additionally, he ordered the release of an audio recording from the hearing, also subject to redaction.
Lawyers representing media outlets argued that making courtroom proceedings open to the public is critical for the integrity of the judicial system, fostering public confidence in fair and transparent trials. Graf has further clarified that Robinson's restraints should not be visible in any media broadcasts or photographs from court.
During the latest hearing, Robinson appeared remotely from Utah County Jail, as a preliminary hearing is set for the week of May 18, where prosecutors will detail their case against him.
