According to Patrick Parenteau, a professor specializing in environmental law, the 'God Squad' has only intervened in three cases since its formation, with two projects being approved and one denied. For a project to cross the ESA's safeguards, members of the committee must agree that significant economic factors justify the violation, requiring at least five out of seven votes to proceed. Critics of Trump's proposed use of the panel caution that stringent legal processes must first be observed, indicating that plans to circumvent the ESA are not guaranteed to succeed.

This latest move has sparked significant debates about the balance of environmental conservation versus economic growth, making the actions of the 'God Squad' a focal point for future policy discussions.