Judge Caprio's courtroom was a space where personal stories mattered, often evident in his heartfelt approach to sentencing. He famously brought a sense of warmth to the judicial process, from inviting children to sit beside him during hearings to creating a soft toy likeness called "mini-judge." A viral TikTok showcasing his morning routine resonated with many, highlighting the simplicity and joy he found in everyday life.

Tributes poured in from fans and friends who remembered Judge Caprio's unwavering belief in the goodness of people. His son, David Caprio, expressed gratitude for the support and urged others to honor his father's memory by spreading kindness. The official statement on his Instagram account reflected the sentiment shared by his followers, noting the "countless acts of kindness he inspired" throughout his life.

Judge Caprio's impactful career was recognized with multiple Daytime Emmy nominations, showcasing his unique blend of compassion and judicial common sense. His passing marks the end of an era for a figure who has greatly influenced both his community and the wider public through kindness and empathy in the court system. He is survived by his wife, Joyce, along with their five children, seven grandchildren, and two great-grandchildren, leaving a profound and enduring legacy behind.