Musallet's death was confirmed by the Palestinian health ministry, which stated that he was killed during what has been described as a violent altercation instigated by Israeli settlers. The Israeli military has indicated they are looking into the matter, asserting that "terrorists" initiated the conflict by throwing stones at settlers. Musallet's friend, 23-year-old Mohammed al-Shalabi, also lost his life during the incident after being shot in the chest.

The Musallet family revealed that Sayfollah was attempting to protect their agricultural land from encroachment by settlers when tragedy struck. Reports suggest that settlers obstructed an ambulance trying to reach Musallet, who died before receiving medical care. The family has called upon the US State Department to conduct its own investigation into the killings.

Huckabee, who has been a staunch supporter of Israeli settlements deemed illegal under international law, characterized the assault as a "criminal and terrorist act," promising that there should be accountability for the perpetrators. His remarks come amidst criticism from opposition Democrats regarding his historical stances on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Last month, he faced backlash for expressing support for Israeli ministers accused of inciting violence against Palestinians.

The incident involving Musallet has further complicated an already tense relationship between the United States and Israel regarding the treatment of Palestinians in the occupied territories.

As pressure mounts for a more thorough inquiry, questions remain about the larger implications for US foreign policy and support in the region.